The décor of the Nickerson Library is predominantly derived from the English Renaissance style, a conservative style considered suitable for a scholarly room. Ebonized cherry wood was used for the paneling of the room, including the built-in bookcases that line the south and east walls. Throughout the frieze a series of carved panels in maple provide points of contrast within the expanse of ebonized paneling. The 16 smaller square panels of the frieze are each carved with a wreath enclosing a central floral element, while the four larger rectangular panels in the corners of the room feature elaborate floral swags comprised of fruit and foliage. Subtle differences render each panel unique. The walls of the Library have been upholstered with a sumptuous black and gold fabric from Jacquard by Georgette.